 |
| Intova Edge X |
The Intova Edge X was made for the water. It was the
first completely sealed action camera, it was waterproof to 60 metres and was
protected by a tough rubber armoured shell. It also had everything that any
water fanatic or adrenalin junkie would want including GPS, WiFi and an array
of other technical things to excite the amateur underwater photographer. It was
great and we liked it so much we bought one. Now though, our beloved little
armoured friend has developed the rather irritating problem of freezing up.
Yep, just when that huge barracuda came into the view or that massive shoal of
fish headed straight for the lens, the Intova decided to throw a wobbly and
froze. Now, due to the fact that the camera’s warranty had expired, the only way
to solve this problem was to open it up and carry out a reset procedure or hurl
it hard against a wall. Neither though, are very practical solutions when in
the water. So as we begin planning our trips for 2017 we’ve come to the
conclusion that we are going to have to relegate the Edge X to a minor
supporting role and give the lead to another camera but which one?
A few years ago buying an action camera was easy;
you walked into a shop, asked for an action camera and were promptly sold a
small box called a GoPro. Nowadays though, there is so much choice out there, it is hard to
know which camera is best. Fortunately however, there is a font of knowledge
within easy reach. Just a few clicks on the old trusty computer and hey presto
the interwebby gods will present you with a cornucopia of reviews. In fact,
there are so many reviews out there you might start to think that you are the
only person on the planet who hasn’t looked at, compared, tested and studiously
examined every inch of every camera that has ever been made. Which presents
another problem. Which review do you believe? Is the reviewer really
independent or are they being paid to review the camera, in which case was it
an advertisement masquerading as a review? And, perhaps more importantly, does
the review actually help the decision making process?
Well let’s put it the to the test. We’re going to
look for a new action camera and buy the one the reviews say are the best.
As we liked the Intova Edge X so much, we should probably
start with the Edge X’s direct replacement the X2. The X2 is a striking looking
camera and if looks alone were what we were going for then we would already have hit
the add-to-cart button on this one. But looks aren’t everything are they? So
what do the reviews say. All the reviews highlighted the X2’s inbuilt
flash/video light and the fact that it can take 16mp photos as opposed to the
12mp that is common for this class of camera. The X2 also has a 2 inch LCD screen so you can see what you’re shooting, is waterproof to 60m and like
the Edge X is surrounded by an almost indestructible rubberised shell. Priced
at £300, give or take a few pounds, the X2 isn’t the most expensive camera out there
and every review seems to be in agreement: The X2 is a small, rugged camera
designed to go anywhere and capture that “adventure”. In short, everyone seemed
to like it. Which doesn’t really help does it? Then there is the niggling
thought that although Intova have added a light and made the camera better
looking, the software issue that affects the Edge X may also affect the X2. And, it will probably affect it exactly one day after the warranty expires too.
That said though, we like Intova and as all the reviews confirm, the X2 is a
well-designed camera that seems to suit our needs. But, before we calm our
niggling doubts over the software with some cold beer and part with £300, is
there anything else out there that’s better?
 |
| Intova X2 |
Well Intova isn’t the only manufacturer we like.
Last year we bought an Olympus TG-4 and we liked it a lot. Now Olympus has
launched its own action camera onto the market. It’s called the Tracker and
unlike most manufacturers in the sector, Olympus have not decided to follow the
GoPro box design but have gone for a smaller version of a traditional camcorder
design. Being part of the Tough range of cameras the Tracker is freezeproof,
crushproof, shockproof and waterproof to 30m. The Tracker has an inbuilt light
for shooting in low light and has an auto detect feature that automatically senses
it’s underwater and switches to optimal mode for shooting beneath the waves. It also has a wide
angle lens and one of the fastest shutter speeds of any camera in its class,
which means it’s great for action shots. The Tracker looks good too. So what do
the reviews make of this camera? Well, everyone liked it. They really did, it
got a 5/5 in some ratings and depending on the retailer, you can pick up a
Tracker for less than £270, which makes it cheaper than the X2. The Tracker
also has 4k video resolution unlike the X2. However, the X2 has 16mp resolution
whilst the Tracker has only 8mp. Now some reviews pointed out that the
Tracker’s LCD screen only flips out rather than flipping out and rotating. Now
if we had a problem with flipping screens not rotating then this could be deal
breaker but we don’t. So there you have it. We are going to push the X2 aside
and buy a Tracker. After all, the reviews all say it’s great. But then they
said the X2 was great as well didn’t they? Err… This is getting confusing.
Maybe we should look around a bit more. See what else is available.
 |
| Olympus TG-Tracker with pistol grip |
After all, we haven’t even considered the elephant
in the room yet have we? We are of course talking about the GoPro Hero 5 Black.
The Hero 5 sits like a smug cat atop the ever-growing pile of GoPro imitators
that exist in the action camera sector, according to some reviews at least. Now we have never really liked GoPro’s.
We never liked the boxiness, the lack of a view screen, the unbelievably
expensive range of accessories and the sense that if we ever bought one we’d
have to grow our hair long, dye it blonde, take up snowboarding, start
using the word “radical” in everyday conversation, change our name to Tristan
Hansard-Faffyman and become friends with Gareth “I own a fairtrade coffee shop”
Beardybloke. You know what we mean here. GoPros' were for Lycra-clad nutcases
on overpriced bicycles or baggy trousered snowboarders that hurtle down the
slopes knocking everyone else over. They were not for snorkellers, freedivers
or bubble blowers. But GoPro seemed to have picked up on this and made the
GoPro Hero 5 more appealing to people who don’t shout all the time. Firstly it
has an inbuilt 2 inch LCD screen so you can frame the shot. It has 4k video
resolution, shoots 12mp photos, has an easy to use touch screen menu and comes
complete with all the usual accoutrements of WiFi, GPS, video stabilisation and
the rest. What makes this model really appealing is the fact that it is
waterproof to 10m without a separate housing, making it perfect for
snorkelling. Anyway what did the reviews say? Well, rather disappointingly,
they all loved the Hero 5. Praise was universally gushing and it even got 5/5
on some reviews. People even praised the box it came in. It’s like wanting a sports
car isn’t it? If you can afford a Ferrari why buy a Porsche. Likewise, if you
can afford an expensive camera, why buy anything other than a GoPro Hero 5.
Unless of course you realise that the GoPro 6 is due out later this year and in
the world of shouty Tristan’s and lycra-clad cyclists, owning a 5 when a 6 is
available is like getting your coffee from McDonalds rather than Beardyblokes
Shangri-La Native Coffee Emporium. It’s just not fashionable and not being
fashionable means that Tristan’s sister Jemima, nor any of her friends, will
want to sleep with you. Yet the Hero 5 is still very popular and there is no doubting the quality of the video or
photographs that are produced, so maybe it’s time to swallow our pride and join
the shouty set. After all, all the reviews recommend it don’t they? So it is
the one for us.
 |
| Buy one of these and Jemima might sleep with you |
But wait. Maybe our prejudices run too deep and
maybe we’re happy to be the only people in the pub who haven’t slept with
Jemima and her friends so surely there must be another camera out there that stands
up to the GoPro? What about the SeaLife Micro 2 HD or the new DC1400 or the
DC1200 elite? What about the Nikon KeyMission 170 and then there are the
cheaper versions like the Veho Muvi series, the Garmin Virbin or even the iSaw
Edge? What do the reviews say about them? Well, that’s the problem really. All
the reviews like all of them. So we’re back to square one really. We
want to buy a camera but are not sure which is the best so maybe we should
ignore the reviews altogether and just set some parameters.
The camera should be waterproof without a housing.
It should be easy to operate underwater. It should be able to take 12mp images
or above. It should be compatible with Intova and GoPro clips and accessories
and it should be less than £500. Right, that’s the Intova X2 then. Oh, but
wait, that doesn’t have 4K! Well it’ll be the Hero 5 then… But wait, do we all
want to change our name to Tristan? It’s the Olympus Tracker then. But wait
that doesn’t do 12mp and the screen doesn’t rotate and maybe that will be a
problem. Ohh…. This is becoming ridiculous… We’re going to need to read some
more reviews. Visit some more photography sites and do an in-depth comparison.
Barman, we’re going to need more beer… Or maybe… We can get the Edge X fixed.
Right… Camera repair shops; which is the best one?
Right… Camera repair shops; which is the best one?
 |
| Is this any good? How should we know? |
No comments:
Post a Comment